Rights of the Husband greater than the Father

Is the status of the Husband greater than the husband


  • Total voters
    38
She can visit her dying father with her husband and children. What would there be to attend to? You are using an extreme example that doesn’t make sense.

Funnily enough, he is using the Shafi madhab to argue he can stop her, when in the Shafii madhab the wife does not even have to cook for him.
 

Gibiin-Udug

Crowned Queen of Puntland. Supporter of PuntExit
@Afrique Ive a friend who once told me she’s going to ask her husband if she can go out with our group of friends, we all laughed at her, he even laughed at her and said I’m not your keeper. He cracked jokes in our text group chat. We both need to find such a man!
 

Samaalic Era

QurboExit
Just because in some schools of thought she may have to obey you, does not mean you are not sinning for stopping her.

It is haraam for a man to stop his wife from visiting her family.
He can it's not haram, just as you mentioned she doesn't have to cook and clean

You can't pick and choose :comeon:
 

Gambar

VIP
Funnily enough, he is using the Shafi madhab to argue he can stop her, when in the Shafii madhab the wife does not even have to cook for him.
He’s being extreme to fit an agenda (because the other day it was about not having to pay mehr). Good luck with marriage walal. Imagine starting a fight over you not being able to leave to visit your dying father because you have to tend to the children and house when you can all go visit him together? Is he not your father in law and the children’s grandfather? Just sounds petty.
 

Basic

Passive Aggressive is the new Aggressive
VIP
I met a toxic farax once who said I’ll have the final say in everything and you must obey me. Mind you this guy wasn’t qualified to lead an ant let alone a fully functioning adult. :susp:

A gaal ajnabi was more appealing than him:banderas:
 

Gambar

VIP
@Afrique Ive a friend who once told me she’s going to ask her husband if she can go out with our group of friends, we all laughed at her, he even laughed at her and said I’m not your keeper. He cracked jokes in our text group chat. We both need to find such a man!
Sounds like she just didn’t wanna go loooool sorta like when you use your kids as an excuse. I don’t have a baby sitter. You just don’t wanna go.
 

Medulla

Bah Qabiil Fluid
I met a toxic farax once who said I’ll have the final say in everything and you must obey me. Mind you this guy wasn’t qualified to lead an ant let alone a fully functioning adult. :susp:

A gaal ajnabi was more appealing than him:banderas:

Gaals ajnabis are the new wave build them the way you like convert em and you got a keeper

:yousmart:
 

Gibiin-Udug

Crowned Queen of Puntland. Supporter of PuntExit
Sounds like she just didn’t wanna go loooool sorta like when you use your kids as an excuse. I don’t have a baby sitter. You just don’t wanna go.
She did, she started doing that when she went back to Dugsi.
 
I met a toxic farax once who said I’ll have the final say in everything and you must obey me. Mind you this guy wasn’t qualified to lead an ant let alone a fully functioning adult. :susp:

A gaal ajnabi was more appealing than him:banderas:
You sure we havent met? Thats my line
 
He can it's not haram, just as you mentioned she doesn't have to cook and clean

You can't pick and choose :comeon:

I'm not picking and choosing.

It is haraam, but she still has to obey you.
You will be questioned for making her sever the ties of kinship.

Just because she has to listen to you, doesn't mean you will not be questioned for causing distance between parents and their child.

Btw, i'm not Shafii.
 

Basic

Passive Aggressive is the new Aggressive
VIP
Gaals ajnabis are the new wave build them the way you like convert em and you got a keeper

:yousmart:
Ngl they have more healthy mindset than a lot of third world culture guys I’ve seen. In all seriousness I’d just choose a healthy minded progressive Muslim guy
 
Top