Separating facts from rumors in the Goldogob rape case

[Bahal]

tbh setting nasty precedents in third world countries can often be just as damaging

in this case it is 100% confirmed, in another it may not be as concrete. but without a proper jailing system there is another reason to want capital punishment and that is to safeguard citizens from dangerous individuals.

I think it would set a positive precedent if anything.

This is a country that hasnt been governed by the rule of law for decades, where criminals routinely go unpunished because of their clan ties.

They will think twice now knowing their clan cannot protect them from justice.

 

[Rorschach]

Public flogging and monetary compensation for the girl. The government is also entitled to give them prison time.

what does the punishment according to sharia entail? like what does sharia law say to do in this case?

Rape with the threat of violence incurs the Hudud punishment (crime against God). The punishment(s) are covered in Surah Ma'idah [5:33]:

The punishment of those who wage war against Allah and His Messenger, and strive with might and main for mischief through the land is: execution, or crucifixion, or the cutting off of hands and feet from opposite sides, or exile from the land: that is their disgrace in this world, and a heavy punishment is theirs in the Hereafter;

The presiding judge can choose the punishment based on his own discretion (what would ultimately benefit the community).

According to Somali culture and Islamic teachings: mar hadu wiilku biyo-baxo, wuu qaan-gaaray.

 

[SenseSays]

Age shouldn't be a factor with what they have done to the girl.....They raped and attempted to murder her. If they aren't executed the girls male relatives will get them.

 

[supz]

Execution seems a little lacking tbh. Death would be merciful.

 

[Sixth]

An example must be made out of them, they should be put down like the stray dogs they are.

 

[Mercury]

Execution seems a little lacking tbh. Death would be merciful.

If I was in charge I would burn them one by one

 

[Tenacious]

Someone said the girls are from minority clan that are considered untouchables. No wonder its taking so long to execute these criminals when there is prove of their evil crime.

 

[TheLibertarianQuiche]

The death penalty as a whole is hugely flawed. Use your maskax for once for fucks sake.

He became an alt-right fangirl after he learnt they might give him ictiraaf.

 

[Thegoodshepherd]

Puntland does not have the resources to hold these animals in jail for decades. There does not even need to be a trial, all of their faces are known. Simply verify you have the same faces and

@Tenacious
Not true, the girl is from the same subclan as the perpetrators.

 

[TheLibertarianQuiche]

So you would like the Tax payer to pay for their food, clothing and other facilities. Sxb, i highly doubt you would support that method of "punishment" if it were one of your female relatives was attacked and treated like an object by these scumbags. Why waste money on these disgusting criminals when you can just execute them? Its a no brainer.

For this case or rapes/murders in general?

Life in prison without parole. They should never see the light of day..

This is the solution:

Life without parole in solitary confinement without visitation rights and give them just enough to eat and drink (meal and a litre of water a week).

Death is the easy way out.

 

[dhegdheer]

Hold up they're 16? nah man you lot made it sound like they were younger. They can die screaming for all I care

 

[Zuleikha]

They're still underage and the girl did not die. Executing them will be wrong tbh. Anything other than the death penalty would be fine though.

Excuses excuses excuses. They are 16+ year olds. In somalia the average 16 and something year olds hold responsibilties such having their own family. Don't make it seem like they were under 12 year old, even the 10 year old knows what is right and wrong its effing common sense.

They are animals and danger to other young girls if they don't get executed.

If my own family did something like this I would be the first to advocate their execution.

 

[Abdalla]

They shouldn't be charged just for rape, they committed several crimes:

-They took her to a remote place so that's abduction
-They stabbed her (attempting murder)
-They beat her up severely (severe assault and battering)
-They recorded her so they had some kind of leverage on her to have sex with them (blackmailing/extortion)
-By spreading the tapes they should be punished for defamation

 

[TheLibertarianQuiche]

Apparently some guy from the town was saying that the girl who raped, her brother raped one of the guys sisters and it was a revenge attack, Can anyone verify it?

The girl is from a langaab tribe so I doubt it.

 

[Mercury]

This is the solution:

Life without parole in solitary confinement without visitation rights and give them just enough to eat and drink (meal and a litre of water a week).

Death is the easy way out.

Sure death is a easy way out But I think a public execution where they are burned to death is better

 

[Duchess]

The girl is from a langaab tribe so I doubt it.

Stop the disinformation. All involved are from the same clan.

I also haven't heard anything about her brother raping one of the guy's sister. It sounds like something someone who is making excuses for the rapists would spread.

 

[TheLibertarianQuiche]

Stop the disinformation. All involved are from the same clan.

I also haven't heard anything about her brother raping one of the guy's sister. It sounds like something someone who is making excuses for the rapists would spread.

I heard they were madhibaan. But okay.

I think its just justification to protect that politicians child.

 

[TheLibertarianQuiche]

Sure death is a easy way out But I think a public execution where they are burned to death is better

Nah burning to death is a bit 1400's.

I would prefer barely-feeding them in solitary confinement for the rest of their lives. If they're found innocent, all that publicly denounced the crime online should donate towards compensation. Sound good?

 

[Transparent]

I heard they were madhibaan. But okay.

I think its just justification to protect that politicians child.

she's leelkase which if i am right is pretty langaab and goldogob is mainly inhabited by leelkase

 

[TheLibertarianQuiche]

she's leelkase which if i am right is pretty langaab and goldogob is mainly inhabited by leelkase

My point exactly @Duchess

If she was MJ she would have an upper-hand but since they're the same tribe and they're male then she is already at a disadvantage.