Thoughts on this take? Are secular Somalis increasing within the western hemisphere?

World

VIP
Ok ifyou prefer. secularism why dont you live in North Korea. You're a troglodyte and if you deny
sharia you're a kaffir
You said that Al Shabab exist because of Somalia’s secularism. Why do you not prefer to live in Jilib, which is the solution for Somalia’s secularism, but instead prefer to live in the even more secular West? What you are saying are just empty words that contradict your actions. You’ve defined the antidote for secularism clearly, so go and act on it.
 
Last edited:
I don't people are. But the more educated you are the more open minded you are going to be. There is nothing wrong in that.

Somalia need to reject islamism which is dying worldwide and have a process of decolonization that implenemts a fair and equitable system with Somali 'characteristics'. Not Arab ones.

Look at Iran. More people are leaving Islam in Iran than any other country. Who wants morality police in the street telling them what to do.
 

Galool

VIP
I don't people are. But the more educated you are the more open minded you are going to be. There is nothing wrong in that.

Somalia need to reject islamism which is dying worldwide and have a process of decolonization that implenemts a fair and equitable system with Somali 'characteristics'. Not Arab ones.

Look at Iran. More people are leaving Islam in Iran than any other country. Who wants morality police in the street telling them what to do.

Actually studies shows that when Muslims are more educated they are more religious. You people use Iran and other Christian nations trajectory and falsely assume it is the same with Islam. History and statistics proves you wrong over and over again.

The reason education makes them leave their religion but makes Muslims more religious is because their religions are false and Islam (Sunni) is the truth.

Islamism is a made up western word. What they mean by it is Islam itself. Islam itself is all encompassing and includes Islamic government and laws, one who denies it ceases to be Muslim. So Islam and it’s adherence including what liberals and Kafirs call “islamism” is resurgent and growing everywhere, not dying.

cry about it.
 
Actually studies shows that when Muslims are more educated they are more religious. You people use Iran and other Christian nations trajectory and falsely assume it is the same with Islam. History and statistics proves you wrong over and over again.

The reason education makes them leave their religion but makes Muslims more religious is because their religions are false and Islam (Sunni) is the truth.

Islamism is a made up western word. What they mean by it is Islam itself. Islam itself is all encompassing and includes Islamic government and laws, one who denies it ceases to be Muslim. So Islam and it’s adherence including what liberals and Kafirs call “islamism” is resurgent and growing everywhere, not dying.

cry about it.

I'm not a fan of the west. I never mentioned the west. My original post referred to wholesale decolonization of Somalia with one that implements a fair and equitable system with Somali 'characteristics'.

What many want is a system where primacy of the rule of law, justice, dignity and equity for all like the one that prevails in Singapore and certainly not theocratic rule like in Iran or Afghanistan which overtime has proven itself to be corrupt and cruel. These turban heads issue harsh order than retreat to homes surrounded by high walls where they consume alcohol, smoke hashish or in the case of Afghanistan cavort with young boys. Its on public record.

No where in the Muslim are people are clamouring to leave Islam than in the Islamic Republic of Iran. In Afghanistan millions live in utter destitution and clamour to flee the 'Islamic Republic' and the morality police in the streets.

As for these Sheikhs in Somalia - they have proven themselves to be under the thumb of corrupt mooryans or whatever prevailing order - issuing fatwas and orders that is a mockery of Islam.

Just this week, they assembled three shiekhs in Mogadishu who issued a call that they can use as a cover to dig up graves in land they want to develop. How pitiful.

Its symbol of the decay and weakness Islam countries are in today. 2 billion Muslims cower in fright and indignation at a tiny nation of 9 million like Israel who they cannot beat.

There is no compulsion in Islam and thats the way it should be. A personal connection and understanding between you and Allah and that is it.

Leave the state and me out of it.
 
Last edited:
At that stage of a child's life, there's nothing he can do to stop her irreligiosity.

He should have planted the seeds for her to be an upright Muslimah 15 years ago. It sounds like he had a very hands-off approach with regards to building her religious foundation so naturally she'd be more easily inclined to being a murtad than your average Western-born Somali.

Oh well!
:kobeok:
He should discipline her even now
 
What we want is a system where the rule of law prevails like Singapore and certainly not theocractic rule like in Iran or Afghanistan which overtime has proven itself to be corrupt and decayed.

No where in the Muslim are people are clamouring to leave Islam than in the Islamic Republic of Iran.

In Afghanistan millions live in destitution and clamour to flee the 'Islamic Republic'.

As for these Sheikhs in Somalia have proven themselves to be under the thumb of corrupt mooryans issuing fatwas and orders that have no relvancy to 99% of people.

They assembled three shiekhs in Mogadishu who issued a fatwa they can use as a cover to dig up graves in land they want to develop. How pitiful.

Its symbol of the decay and weakness Islam countries are in today. 2 billion Muslims cower in fright and indignation at a tiny nation of 9 million like Israel.

There is no compulsion in Islam and thats the way it should be. A personal connection and understanding between you and Allah and that is it.

Leave the state out of it.
The rule of law prevails in the theocratic government's of Iran and Afghanistan too. what you want is a secular rule in the Muslim world where the laws of Allah are discarded for corrupt and alien anti-Islamic laws which of course is not possibility or choice for us Muslims.

قال تعالى: أفحكم الجاهلية يبغون ومن أحسن من الله حكما لقوم يوقنون

وقال تعالي أيضا في سورة آل عمران: أفغير دين الله يبغون وله أسلم من في السموات والأرض طوعا وكرها وإليه يرجعون

This last ayah solidifies that there is no religion to be followed other than the religion of Allah Islam and all those in earth and heavens must submit to him
 

KinsiHilaac

Pretend there is a title here

Let's have an honest, civilized discussion about this topic without resorting to "Muh Murtad n shiet.

As we should and we annsoljtely are increasing .
Most Somalis (the intelligent) ones realize that there is no point bringing sharia to the countries we are in right now when we ran from ours for the same reason.

No hate or anything but at one point every civilized society learns that people are humans first irrespective of religion.
Cheers

Let's have an honest, civilized discussion about this topic without resorting to "Muh Murtad n shiet.


Yeah we secular Somalis are increasing
The intelligent Somalis realize that there is no point trying to make the countries we are in right now- resemble the country we ran from.

Secularism for the win and no offense but every civilized society realized at Ike point that being a human comes first, religion and personal belief comes second.
 

al-Mu'tamid المعتمد

عِشْ مَا شِئْتَ فَإِنَّكَ مَيِّتٌ
Most Somalis (the intelligent) ones realize that there is no point bringing sharia to the countries we are in right now when we ran from ours for the same reason.

No hate or anything but at one point every civilized society learns that people are humans first irrespective of religion.
Cheers



Yeah we secular Somalis are increasing
The intelligent Somalis realize that there is no point trying to make the countries we are in right now- resemble the country we ran from.

Secularism for the win and no offense but every civilized society realized at Ike point that being a human comes first, religion and personal belief comes second.
"The intelligent Somalis"
1718135023167.png
 
He should discipline her even now
You're the same guy who kept defending the man who burned his pregnant wife alive.

I know exactly what your idea of 'discipline' is and let me tell you, it will only serve to reinforce her reasons for leaving Islam.
 
Secularism - Western Colony

Islam - Not Arab colony apparently (Arabic also official language) :rolleyes:
Caqli xuma. Somalia is a Muslim nation, Islam is not foreign to us but secularism is.
You guys can promote secularism in the west no problem, but why are you so eager to force such a notion of no religion in the state when the majority of Muslims residing in the Muslim lands believe that only Allah is the true legislatior and the Muslim ruler is only the vicegerent of God on earth?

Go to anywhere in Somalia and ask people do you believe the xukum/legislation only belongs to Allah and they will 99% give you a resounding yes!

So do you see the problem with the people who are thinking that secularism will work in Somalia or that this Alien concept would be accepted by the people?

The only way this can be applied is by occupation and force or puppet governments...and that's what is going on now in Somalia and all over the Muslim world. Muslims who are being forced to live in systems that are contradictory to Islam...if the west left them to themselves you will see Islamic Emirates taking over the whole Muslim world..supported by their Muslim citizens.

I don't know why Western political discourse thinks that they can change the beliefs and values of nearly 2 billion Muslims by force...its a losing battle and one they will only grow tired of.
 

Galool

VIP
I'm not a fan of the west. I never mentioned the west. My original post referred to wholesale decolonization of Somalia with one that implements a fair and equitable system with Somali 'characteristics'.

What many want is a system where primacy of the rule of law, justice, dignity and equity for all like the one that prevails in Singapore and certainly not theocratic rule like in Iran or Afghanistan which overtime has proven itself to be corrupt and cruel. These turban heads issue harsh order than retreat to homes surrounded by high walls where they consume alcohol, smoke hashish or in the case of Afghanistan cavort with young boys. Its on public record.

No where in the Muslim are people are clamouring to leave Islam than in the Islamic Republic of Iran. In Afghanistan millions live in utter destitution and clamour to flee the 'Islamic Republic' and the morality police in the streets.

As for these Sheikhs in Somalia - they have proven themselves to be under the thumb of corrupt mooryans or whatever prevailing order - issuing fatwas and orders that is a mockery of Islam.

Just this week, they assembled three shiekhs in Mogadishu who issued a call that they can use as a cover to dig up graves in land they want to develop. How pitiful.

Its symbol of the decay and weakness Islam countries are in today. 2 billion Muslims cower in fright and indignation at a tiny nation of 9 million like Israel who they cannot beat.

There is no compulsion in Islam and thats the way it should be. A personal connection and understanding between you and Allah and that is it.

Leave the state and me out of it.

Which religion are you speaking about? Islam and the state are one and the same, it is in the Seerah, in the Quran, a pillar of the faith, throughout history. Do you think modern western secularism is part of Islam?

It will never be left out as it is an integral part. All Muslims know this, even children.

Secularism, separation of church and state and personal faith is an alien concept to Islam only found in the modern west. You can choose which faith you wish to follow Islam or liberalism/secularism but Islam will never change.

The verse about no compulsion in Islam is about forcing non-Muslims to accept Islam. That is forbidden and people must choose it. Yet all Muslims know there is the Shariah, laws that are compulsory and that the Khilafah would implement. Apostates are executed. So yes, there is compulsion. A lot of liberals try to use this verse to misconstrue Islam to fit liberalism.

Your repeating lies about Afghanistan and speaking about a Shia state again.

Islam will never be secular and Muslims only become more religious as time passes, all studies show this.
 
Which religion are you speaking about? Islam and the state are one and the same, it is in the Seerah, in the Quran, a pillar of the faith, throughout history. Do you think modern western secularism is part of Islam?

It will never be left out as it is an integral part. All Muslims know this, even children.

Secularism, separation of church and state and personal faith is an alien concept to Islam only found in the modern west. You can choose which faith you wish to follow Islam or liberalism/secularism but Islam will never change.

The verse about no compulsion in Islam is about forcing non-Muslims to accept Islam. That is forbidden and people must choose it. Yet all Muslims know there is the Shariah, laws that are compulsory and that the Khilafah would implement. Apostates are executed. So yes, there is compulsion. A lot of liberals try to use this verse to misconstrue Islam to fit liberalism.

Your repeating lies about Afghanistan and speaking about a Shia state again.

Islam will never be secular and Muslims only become more religious as time passes, all studies show this.

Facts however don't support your islamist or fundamentalist position. As people get educated they move away from islamism. In fact throughout the world. Islamism is dying. The outlier is poor, corrupt and wretched places like Somalia. Where there is very low literacy rates, no education system and no justice. Religion is the only thing left in their lives. Even in Saudi Arabia. No one is interested in it anymore like they were in the 80s or 90s. They seen what it done to Iran and Afghanistan.
 
Caqli xuma. Somalia is a Muslim nation, Islam is not foreign to us but secularism is.
You guys can promote secularism in the west no problem, but why are you so eager to force such a notion of no religion in the state when the majority of Muslims residing in the Muslim lands believe that only Allah is the true legislatior and the Muslim ruler is only the vicegerent of God on earth?

Go to anywhere in Somalia and ask people do you believe the xukum/legislation only belongs to Allah and they will 99% give you a resounding yes!

So do you see the problem with the people who are thinking that secularism will work in Somalia or that this Alien concept would be accepted by the people?

The only way this can be applied is by occupation and force or puppet governments...and that's what is going on now in Somalia and all over the Muslim world. Muslims who are being forced to live in systems that are contradictory to Islam...if the west left them to themselves you will see Islamic Emirates taking over the whole Muslim world..supported by their Muslim citizens.

I don't know why Western political discourse thinks that they can change the beliefs and values of nearly 2 billion Muslims by force...its a losing battle and one they will only grow tired of.
Not foreign? Which Somali started Islam exactly? It's not even native to Africa, let alone Somalia. You don't even pray in your own language but a foreign one.

Also most Muslim majority nations are not like Somalia, the more developed and more education a country has, the less religious.
 
Facts however don't support your islamist or fundamentalist position. As people get educated they move away from islamism. In fact throughout the world. Islamism is dying. The outlier is poor, corrupt and wretched places like Somalia. Where there is very low literacy rates, no education system and no justice. Religion is the only thing left in their lives. Even in Saudi Arabia. No one is interested in it anymore like they were in the 80s or 90s. They seen what it done to Iran and Afghanistan.
Stop acting like people who follow Islam are lacking IQ and the ones who move away from it are enlightened beings. It's not about being more educated, rather its choosing a belief system to follow.

A Muslim believes in God, His sovereignty and that he sent Islam as a guidance to mankind and so submits himself to God in all spheres of his life. Just as a Muslim holds this as a belief system, the secularist also holds a belief system...the belief that man is his own sovereign, he is free to do as he wishes and follow his desires with no constraints.

This belief system has come about from exposure to the western way of thought and culture...and so just as we have chosen Islam as the ultimate truth, the secularists have chosen a Godless society as their ultimate truth.
Not foreign? Which Somali started Islam exactly? It's not even native to Africa, let alone Somalia. You don't even pray in your own language but a foreign one.

Also most Muslim majority nations are not like Somalia, the more developed and more education a country has, the less religious.
Keep following your falsehood... I don't get why you care about Muslims or their lands when it doesnt concern you...just enjoy your liberalism way of life in the west.
 
Stop acting like people who follow Islam are lacking IQ and the ones who move away from it are enlightened beings. It's not about being more educated, rather its choosing a belief system to follow.

A Muslim believes in God, His sovereignty and that he sent Islam as a guidance to mankind and so submits himself to God in all spheres of his life. Just as a Muslim holds this as a belief system, the secularist also holds a belief system...the belief that man is his own sovereign, he is free to do as he wishes and follow his desires with no constraints.

This belief system has come about from exposure to the western way of thought and culture...and so just as we have chosen Islam as the ultimate truth, the secularists have chosen a Godless society as their ultimate truth.

Keep following your falsehood... I don't get why you care about Muslims or their lands when it doesnt concern you...just enjoy your liberalism way of life in the west.

Its because of people like you that many are leaving Islam and the religion is declining.
Also explains how most muslim world is largely illiterate, impoverished, wretched or killed every day in genocide. People like you have made muslims weak, despised and look down upon on.
 

Bahal

ʜᴀᴄᴋᴇᴅ ᴍᴇᴍʙᴇʀ
VIP
Somalis have always been fairly liberal tbh. The extremism we have today is as foreign as the extreme secularism, two imports from far away lands contradictory to our history, culture, and traditions.

imo there isn't any need for legislated secularism in an overwhelmingly homogeneous society such as ours, but I also think religion should be kept far away from politics because of the inherently dirty nature of the latter.

The culima should be concerned for our souls, not running for office. God knows Somalia needs real Islam, which emphasizes unity, community, justice, honesty, and fairness. Unfortunately Islam comes a distant second to the true religion of the masses, qabiil, which always takes precedence if we're being honest.

Our society is depraved and morally bankrupt, where rape, robbery, and murder are widespread, condoned, and can always be justified by the God of Qabiil. That should be our focus, not regulating skirt lengths.
 
Its because of people like you that many are leaving Islam and the religion is declining.
Also explains how most muslim world is largely illiterate, impoverished, wretched or killed every day in genocide. People like you have made muslims weak, despised and look down upon on.

So much naceeb. War horta Muslim ma tahay?
 

Trending

Top