I mostly agree with the assessment that Somalis are mostly homogenous. But it is a fact that Cadcad are indeed paternally Asiatic. You disputing that puts you in the clown category since no one disputes this and there are others on this forum who are far more and I mean far more clued up in this. Even the history of Xamar attests to the fact that cadcads are the descendants of Asiatic traders. Also, the fact that you ignore Carab Salaxs, also makes me think youβre a clown as well.
As for cadcads, If they had paternal Somali origins, they wouldnβt have been otherized and seen as ethnic minorities for generations. Their own oral history attests to them being Arab and of Persian origin as well and being different to ethnic Somalis.
@Step a side can you please tell us if Gibil Cad and not Gibil madow whom we know are in Fact Hawiye are paternally Somali?
Also, itβs telling that you refuse to talk about Carab Salax as that will undo all of your claims.
If you said, hey, Somalis are indeed mostly homogenous and but also understood that Gibil caad are mostly paternally Asiatic and that Carab Salah do have Mehri origins which is not disputed, youβd make a lot of sense.